{"key":"b6efbdff8d","origin":"osm","osm_id":"n9969124007","category":"Camping","subcategory":"Public Campground","community":"Salmon Beach","lat":48.9218122,"lon":-125.3244587,"verdict":"include","name":{"value":"Dodd Island","source":"enrichment"},"description":{"value":"Dodd Island is a backcountry island campsite in the Broken Group Islands unit of Pacific Rim National Park Reserve, reachable only by boat — a paddler's and sea-kayaker's destination set in a sheltered, wildlife-rich archipelago off Vancouver Island's west coast; no road access means cyclists must arrive by water, making it a logistical undertaking rather than a touring stop.","source":"camping"},"website":{"value":"https://parks.canada.ca/pn-np/bc/pacificrim/activ/camping","source":"enrichment"},"address":{"value":"Dodd Island, Alberni-Clayoquot, BC V0R 3A0, Canada","source":"review_edit"},"phone":{"value":null,"source":null},"email":{"value":"information@pc.gc.ca","source":"html"},"route_slugs":[],"centrally_administered":false,"bike_parking_detail":null,"raw_osm":{"fee":"yes","name":"Dodd Island","tourism":"camp_site","website":"https://parks.canada.ca/pn-np/bc/pacificrim/activ/camping"},"enrichment_extras":{"reasoning":"Dodd Island is tagged as a tourism=camp_site in OSM, situated at coordinates placing it in the Broken Group Islands unit of Pacific Rim National Park Reserve. The Parks Canada website confirms backcountry camping on seven islands in the Broken Group Islands but specifies they are 'accessible only by boat' — no bike access to this island exists. All detailed amenity data on the page (showers, flush toilets, electrical, food storage, etc.) explicitly describes Green Point Campground in the Long Beach Unit, not Dodd Island or the Broken Group Islands, so those amenities cannot be attributed to this record.","concerns":["Dodd Island is boat-access only — the Parks Canada website explicitly states Broken Group Islands camping is 'accessible only by boat'; no cycling route reaches this island.","The Parks Canada camping page provides no amenity details specific to Dodd Island or the Broken Group Islands — all detailed facility information (showers, flush toilets, electrical, food storage) applies exclusively to Green Point Campground in the Long Beach Unit and must not be attributed to this record.","OSM record contains no address, phone, or email — only a website URL pointing to the general Pacific Rim National Park Reserve camping overview page, not a Dodd Island-specific page.","No mention of reservations, hiker/biker rates, or any other cyclist-relevant amenity in the Broken Group Islands section of the website."],"recommended_status_reason":"Dodd Island is accessible only by boat, not by bicycle, which raises a fundamental fit question for a cycling tourism directory. It may merit inclusion as a multi-modal side-trip destination for cycle-tourers combining cycling with paddling, but this warrants human review given the absence of any bike access.","confirmed_open":true,"contact_confirmed":{"phone":null,"website":true,"address":null},"notes":"A dedicated Parks Canada subpage for Broken Group Islands camping may exist and could contain specific amenity details for Dodd Island (water, food caches, tent pads, reservations). The general camping URL in OSM is insufficient to verify individual island-level amenities."},"provenance":{"enrichment_run":"v2","enrichment_model":"sonnet_4.6","verdict_source":"v2_needs_review","category_source":"camping","category_correction_reason":null,"review_priority":false,"sidecars_applied":["camping","subcategory","wow"],"subcategory_source":"name","subcategory_confidence":"med"},"camping":{"character":"destination","bike_access":"hard","price_band":"basic","price_label":"Basic","season":"summer","energy":"active","kid_friendly":"no"},"required_criteria":{},"optional_amenities":{},"unmapped_criteria":{},"region":"Vancouver Island","ownership":"National park","indigenous_role":[],"notability":2,"wow_evidence":"backcountry island campsite in the Broken Group Islands unit of Pacific Rim National Park Reserve, reachable only by boat","tier":"info"}