{"key":"636f186630","origin":"osm","osm_id":"w313887009","category":"Attractions","subcategory":"Park / Nature","community":"Galiano Island","lat":48.9486962,"lon":-123.476608,"verdict":"needs_review","name":{"value":"Pebble Beach Recreation Site","source":"enrichment"},"description":{"value":"Pebble Beach Recreation Site protects several kilometres of undeveloped shoreline and beaches on Galiano Island in the area known to Hul'qumi'num-speaking peoples as Qw'xwulwis. The reserve encompasses a rare archaeological site, mature Coastal Douglas-fir forest, and lands managed by the Galiano Conservancy as part of a long-running ecological restoration program. It is part of the broader Qw'xwulwis – Cable Bay Conservation Area and offers a striking natural coastal setting for visitors arriving by bike or ferry.","source":"sonnet_4.6"},"website":{"value":"https://galianoconservancy.ca/properties/pebble-beach-reserve/","source":"enrichment"},"address":{"value":null,"source":null},"phone":{"value":null,"source":null},"email":{"value":"info@galianoconservancy.ca","source":"html"},"route_slugs":[],"centrally_administered":false,"bike_parking_detail":null,"raw_osm":{"leisure":"nature_reserve","name":"Pebble Beach Recreation Site","ref:FFID":"REC107041","source":"DataBC - Recreation Polygon"},"enrichment_extras":{"reasoning":"The OSM record identifies this as a BC Forest Recreation Site (ref:FFID=REC107041, source=DataBC) tagged as a nature reserve near coordinates that place it on or near Galiano Island. The auto-discovered URL (medium confidence) points to the Galiano Conservancy's 'Pebble Beach Reserve' page, which describes several kilometers of undeveloped shoreline, archaeological sites, and ecological restoration work — consistent with the location but with a name mismatch ('Recreation Site' vs 'Reserve'). The website contains no mention of cyclist-specific amenities such as bike parking, washrooms, or water, so all required and optional criteria default to null; the phone and address on the website belong to the Galiano Conservancy organization generally, not this specific site.","concerns":["Name mismatch: OSM uses 'Pebble Beach Recreation Site' (a BC Forest Recreation Site, ref:FFID=REC107041) but the discovered website refers to 'Pebble Beach Reserve' managed by the Galiano Conservancy — these may be overlapping but distinct designations.","URL was auto-discovered with only medium confidence; the website is the Galiano Conservancy's organizational site, not a dedicated page for this specific recreation site.","OSM community field says 'Chemainus' (on Vancouver Island) but the website and coordinates place this on Galiano Island — the community attribution may be erroneous.","No contact phone or address in OSM; website phone (250-539-2424) and address (10825 Porlier Pass Rd, Galiano Island) belong to the Galiano Conservancy organization, not the reserve itself."],"recommended_status_reason":"The auto-discovered URL has only medium confidence and links to the Galiano Conservancy's 'Pebble Beach Reserve' page rather than a dedicated Recreation Site page, creating a name mismatch with the OSM record. No cyclist amenities are documented, so required criteria cannot be confirmed; a human reviewer should verify the correct URL, confirm on-site facilities, and determine whether this natural area provides enough cyclist utility for a WWC listing.","confirmed_open":true,"contact_confirmed":{"phone":null,"website":null,"address":null},"notes":"The Galiano Conservancy website confirms the reserve is an active, publicly accessible natural area but provides no information on cyclist-specific infrastructure. A site visit or direct inquiry with the Galiano Conservancy would be needed to assess bike parking, washrooms, and water availability."},"provenance":{"enrichment_run":"v2","enrichment_model":"sonnet_4.6","verdict_source":"enrichment","category_source":"osm","category_correction_reason":null,"review_priority":false,"sidecars_applied":["subcategory","attraction_facets","wow","judgement","price_tier"],"area_dedup":{"absorbed":"230e3b7475"},"subcategory_source":"osm_tag","subcategory_confidence":"high","facets_layers":"l1+l2","judgement":{"verdict_rec":"include","verdict_reason":"public shoreline reserve","confidence":"med"}},"required_criteria":{},"optional_amenities":{},"unmapped_criteria":{},"region":"Vancouver Island","ownership":"Public","indigenous_role":[],"facets":{"dwell":"half","setting":"outdoor","theme":"nature","energy":"active","season":"all","kid_friendly":"yes","visitable":true,"planning":"walk-up","open_early":true,"open_morning":true,"open_afternoon":true,"open_evening":true,"days_closed":[],"is_24h":false,"seasonal_hours":false,"hours_source":"type_prior","facet_confidence":"med"},"notability":1,"wow_evidence":"Kilometres of undeveloped shoreline at Qw'xwulwis with accessible pebble beaches; keeper of the pair with DL 63 (38fe743d02).","rider_delight":2,"blurb":"Wild pebble beaches at Qw'xwulwis on Galiano's northeast shore.","judgement_flags":["dupe_winner"],"price":{"band":0,"band_key":"free","label":"Free","confidence":"high","source":"det_type","signal":"leisure=nature_reserve"},"tier":"info"}