{"key":"5c9f64dd05","origin":"osm","osm_id":"w390177224","category":"Attractions","subcategory":"Park / Nature","community":"Salt Spring Island","lat":48.8511612,"lon":-123.5642123,"verdict":"needs_review","name":{"value":"Bader's Beach Ravine Park Reserve","source":"enrichment"},"description":{"value":"Bader's Beach Ravine Park Reserve is a nature reserve managed within the Capital Regional District system. It offers natural ravine and beach terrain likely of interest to cyclists exploring the region's coastal and forested landscapes. Specific facilities and trail conditions are not documented in available sources.","source":"sonnet_4.6"},"website":{"value":"https://www.crd.ca/parks-recreation/salt-spring-island-parc","source":"enrichment"},"address":{"value":"499 Collins Rd, Salt Spring Island, BC V8K 2N1","source":"review_edit"},"phone":{"value":null,"source":null},"email":{"value":null,"source":null},"route_slugs":[],"centrally_administered":false,"bike_parking_detail":null,"raw_osm":{"leisure":"nature_reserve","name":"Bader's Beach Ravine Park Reserve"},"enrichment_extras":{"reasoning":"The OSM record has only two tags (leisure=nature_reserve and name) with no contact details or amenity data. The discovered URL points to the general CRD Salt Spring Island PARC landing page, which returned only site-wide navigation content with no mention of Bader's Beach Ravine Park Reserve specifically. There is a geographic discrepancy: the OSM community field says 'Duncan' but the managing body URL references Salt Spring Island PARC, and the coordinates (48.85°N, 123.56°W) do not clearly resolve this — no amenity claims can be confirmed from either source.","concerns":["Geographic mismatch: OSM community field is 'Duncan' but the URL points to Salt Spring Island PARC — these are distinct CRD service areas.","No dedicated web page exists for this park; the discovered URL is a general CRD recreation department page that contains no information about Bader's Beach Ravine Park Reserve.","OSM record is extremely sparse: only name and leisure=nature_reserve tags; no address, phone, or amenity data.","URL discovery confidence was rated 'medium' by the discovery process, reinforcing uncertainty about the correct managing body."],"recommended_status_reason":"The OSM record is very sparse (no address, phone, or amenity tags), the discovered website URL leads only to a generic CRD department page with no park-specific content, and there is a geographic mismatch between the OSM community label ('Duncan') and the managing agency (Salt Spring Island PARC). A human reviewer should confirm the park's location, the correct managing-body URL, and whether cyclist-relevant facilities exist before including it.","contact_confirmed":{"phone":null,"website":null,"address":null},"notes":"A search for a dedicated park page (e.g. under CRD regional parks or a Salt Spring Island parks listing) may yield amenity details not available from the current URL."},"provenance":{"enrichment_run":"v2","enrichment_model":"sonnet_4.6","verdict_source":"enrichment","category_source":"osm","category_correction_reason":null,"review_priority":false,"sidecars_applied":["subcategory","attraction_facets","wow","judgement","price_tier"],"subcategory_source":"osm_tag","subcategory_confidence":"high","facets_layers":"l1+l2","judgement":{"verdict_rec":"include","verdict_reason":"Public park reserve, thin evidence.","confidence":"low"}},"required_criteria":{},"optional_amenities":{},"unmapped_criteria":{},"region":"Vancouver Island","ownership":"Public","indigenous_role":[],"facets":{"dwell":"short","setting":"outdoor","theme":"nature","energy":"neutral","season":"all","kid_friendly":"yes","visitable":true,"planning":"walk-up","open_early":true,"open_morning":true,"open_afternoon":true,"open_evening":true,"days_closed":[],"is_24h":false,"seasonal_hours":false,"hours_source":"type_prior","facet_confidence":"med"},"notability":1,"wow_evidence":"Thin record; small CRD reserve near Vesuvius, Salt Spring.","rider_delight":1,"blurb":"Small ravine-and-beach park reserve near Vesuvius.","price":{"band":0,"band_key":"free","label":"Free","confidence":"high","source":"det_type","signal":"leisure=nature_reserve"},"tier":"info"}